Incursion Mode General Feedback

Schroedinger

New Member
Messages
5
Reaction score
3
Kind of writing this as a more general feedback about the Incursion mode itself, rather than just the Abysmal grenade situation.

And right now as of time of posting, Incursion is quite frankly the most blatantly broken mode out of the bunch, featuring more jank and annoyance than real engagement, and Achieving difficulty not due to the actual tactical capability or competency of the enemy force, but plain BS.

And this isn't something i just say in passing, i've played a lot of Incursion by now, in many different ways across different classes, and it's pretty apparent that the Incursion Soldiers by themselves are kinda... not very smart, and can't hit the broad side of a Barn reliably, instead relying on their absolutely ridiculous numbers, (Seriously why does every round of Incursion classify as a certain atrocity with how many of them we have to kill), their suicidal charges, which enable their most annoying move: Grenade Spam.

I've already made a post on Grenade Spam and how ludicrous and annoying it is, so i'll spare that massive issue from this one.

Aside from the obvious issues, recent additions have seen the PAVN equipped with Melee attacks, which also kinda...

I mean, brushing aside the fact that they pull out a knife instantly when in adequate range and land a guaranteed hit once they get to you, they can also apparently 4-hit players, cause fractures with singular strikes, and in my brief taste of their Melee mode, somehow cause several bleed wounds in one hit across multiple parts, which is... it's really hard not to resort to violent language here because of how obscene that is.

Now i can't really speak on their Special forces yet because i really haven't met them much yet, or learned what they do, so imma ignore those rightfully, for now at least.

But yes, those are pretty common issues, if you include them nading into helicopters with Olympic Gold Medalist precision, making Huey's completely useless.

But the main problem with all of these is how they compound due to other issues and gameplay features.

These include, but are certainly not limited to:

- Scale and Population
Frankly, there's too goddamn many of them, even in the slight chunk that actually attacks holds, not to mention that basically the entire map is usually completely swarmed, and how they pick singular chokepoints and angles to cram down on at random, which is nigh-impossible to prepare for, and in some cases, impossible to properly counter with certain map chokepoints, see certain bush hills on Khe Suong.

- Weapon Range
A neat tidbit i found out harshly a bit ago. Most weapons i've gotten my mitts on excluding the Sniper rifle, have an absurd damage falloff over ranges that cause little more than tickles to PAVN Soldiers, so having a scope or extended range on a non-sniper weapon is little more than an advantage in visible range, instead of an increase in effective shooting range. You can practically sink 30 rounds of an M60 into a Soldier within 5 tiles of the visible range without actually critting them, the same goes for the M4A1 Assault Rifle, the Heavy Pulse Rifle, and to a certain extent even the M2. This tidbit pretty much invalidates any attempts to stay out of their Grenade range more easily, which would be the main appeal, shooting them before they can spam grenades, but of course, you'll be blasting whole mags at them with little results. With the Sniper Rifle on the other hand, you'd need a significant amount of Snipers, easily 4 times the normal pick rate, just to get enough Volume of Fire to hold back their sheer numbers.

- Cookoffs
Now, i'm not saying Cookoffs are a bad feature, but they currently stay as the real reason holds fall under Incursion rounds, and are mainly caused by: Grenade Spam. So you're chilling in a trench, suffering screenshake hell as usual, trying to juggle back the 5 grenades they just threw at you, and one of them throws the returned grenade right back, at your M60 and you, boom, gun blows, you blow, explosion spreads to a turret or just some half empty box of ammo, a chain reaction ensues and now the Hold is basically gone, PAVN come storming in, everyone scatters, most of them die because literally the WHOLE MAP is filled with PAVN in amounts no one can beat without fortifications. Now again, Ammo cookoffs are quite realistic, but it's definetly an issue with how much everything explodes on Incursion maps.

- Enemy Deployment Ranges
A phenomenon very often seen on Khe Suong, you're set up around a bush as a natural barrier, firm wall of guns, then boom, PAVN keep dropping in on the SAME spot behind that bush you're next to, always out of firing line, they simply need to turn the corner to chuck nades and blow you up, how fun. But even worse: They drop directly into bases sometimes. And you better hope someone manages to kill all of them before even one of them can throw a grenade, but who am i kidding, they do that shit in one nanosecond anyways. I mean sure, they drop in from above because they paradrop, but normally you can shoot paratroopers in the sky, we can't. Least i'm pretty certain we can't...

Right, that's a pretty cohesive list of stuff that typically happens in an Incursion round, and most of it is kinda bad.

As on how to fix those things? Honestly the main issue is volume of grenades, but enabling the GUNS we have to fire effectively at reasonable ranges would also just... be a good start. And difficulty isn't that hard to keep if their lackluster shooting were to be improved, or they received some AI Upgrades and new capabilities like building their own barricades, heck, they could already gain an advantage if their Sappers actually tried to circumvent defenses instead of being rebranded Soldiers with more boomy gadgets. Hell, giving some of them bulletproof shields that need bigger guns to penetrate would give them a different method to breach defenses without bordering on genuine bullshit, even a Tank unit would be better if we got AT4s or RPGs.

But yes, many issues, many solutions, and Incursion is easily the gamemode that needs the most fixing, by a LOT.

Now i know some people enjoy the torment of this mode and the current state, and i can't argue with personal preference or Masochism, so by all means, you're all completely right and valid, or like... iunno, think of something you like hearing as validation.

My angle, personally, and the reason these complaints are issues for me, is because i enjoy good gameplay loops, and the feeling of becoming better at something, which Incursion hardly fosters well. Don't get me wrong, i like a good challenge, but i don't like bullshit. To me, the gameplay loop of Incursion just feels strained, and lackluster at the same time. You either sit behind an MG or next to the MG, you shoot Soldiers with underwhelming effective range while your screen CONSTANTLY SHAKES like it's trying to give me an Aneurysm or migraine, and every once in a while you get pelted with grenades and have to play ping-pong with the average Pro-CS player in terms of reaction time, only to have your backline fall, or a grenade blow up on you, sure, sometimes you win, sometimes you get out of the falling Hold, and most of the time you get gradually gunned down and pushed into a corner by Human Enemies with no self-preservation instincts. A conclusion that mostly leaves a sour taste, because losing on incursion comes down to little more than luck and chance, whether an enemy Banzai Charge has one or two too many for your line to handle, and how good you and your team are at clicking on a thing and throwing it back, which itself has a chance of being tossed right back anyways. It's frustrating, it's tiring, it heavily limits what strategies i can employ, and my godddd does it get picked way too much on the same map.

Rant over. Done.

I felt like all this shit had to be said, cuz i do like the game on a ground level, and i just easily pick up on negative things until i have to speak my mind to clear it.
This has potential, a lot of it, and for what it's worth, the devs do put a lot of work into it, which i value, so don't go thinking i'm just bitching.
 
Upvote 0
Appreciate the feedback, however I think this is more feedback that indicates the game (or perhaps just the INCURSION mode) is simply not for you. Many of the things you highlight are very much intentional, and basically the entire reason I wanted to make the game.
the reason these complaints are issues for me, is because i enjoy good gameplay loops
This is probably the source of the confusion - I very much do not enjoy making games with "good gameplay loops". I made this game to indulge some things I have long wanted to try make a game with/using.

The key thing is: I suspect that many (but not all!) of your pain points will get worse, especially for the INCURSION mode as things are added.

What you can do if you use the discord, is make sure your discord round notifications are set for other rounds, other than incursion - then you won't be pinged about them.
 
And this isn't something i just say in passing, i've played a lot of Incursion by now, in many different ways across different classes, and it's pretty apparent that the Incursion Soldiers by themselves are kinda... not very smart, and can't hit the broad side of a Barn reliably, instead relying on their absolutely ridiculous numbers, (Seriously why does every round of Incursion classify as a certain atrocity with how many of them we have to kill), their suicidal charges, which enable their most annoying move: Grenade Spam.
Their AI isn't the smartest, and their accuracy has been nerfed twice since release, at release they were very dangerous as a squad of them focusing on you would delete you very fast without cover. Their numbers have also been doubled a week or two ago.
I mean, brushing aside the fact that they pull out a knife instantly when in adequate range and land a guaranteed hit once they get to you, they can also apparently 4-hit players, cause fractures with singular strikes, and in my brief taste of their Melee mode, somehow cause several bleed wounds in one hit across multiple parts, which is... it's really hard not to resort to violent language here because of how obscene that is.
The melee thing is very annoying as they do it even if they don't see you, like if you're hidden and they pass by you they still knife you (in a smoke, prone in darkness, etc.). It also does more damage than if they just shot you which is...?
But yes, those are pretty common issues, if you include them nading into helicopters with Olympic Gold Medalist precision, making Huey's completely useless.
This only happens when the helicopter is flying too low. Pilot issue.
- Weapon Range
A neat tidbit i found out harshly a bit ago. Most weapons i've gotten my mitts on excluding the Sniper rifle, have an absurd damage falloff over ranges that cause little more than tickles to PAVN Soldiers, so having a scope or extended range on a non-sniper weapon is little more than an advantage in visible range, instead of an increase in effective shooting range. You can practically sink 30 rounds of an M60 into a Soldier within 5 tiles of the visible range without actually critting them, the same goes for the M4A1 Assault Rifle, the Heavy Pulse Rifle, and to a certain extent even the M2. This tidbit pretty much invalidates any attempts to stay out of their Grenade range more easily, which would be the main appeal, shooting them before they can spam grenades, but of course, you'll be blasting whole mags at them with little results. With the Sniper Rifle on the other hand, you'd need a significant amount of Snipers, easily 4 times the normal pick rate, just to get enough Volume of Fire to hold back their sheer numbers.
The same damage fall off also applies to their weapons, however you're blowing this way out of proportion. Within the vertical view range, you can 2-4 tap VC in the head just fine with the stock Mk2, but horizontally they take less damage as you see more horizontally than vertically.
I do get the MG and scoped weapon damage fall off hate, but it would be too easy if you could just instakill them wayyy outside their range.
- Cookoffs
Now, i'm not saying Cookoffs are a bad feature, but they currently stay as the real reason holds fall under Incursion rounds, and are mainly caused by: Grenade Spam. So you're chilling in a trench, suffering screenshake hell as usual, trying to juggle back the 5 grenades they just threw at you, and one of them throws the returned grenade right back, at your M60 and you, boom, gun blows, you blow, explosion spreads to a turret or just some half empty box of ammo, a chain reaction ensues and now the Hold is basically gone, PAVN come storming in, everyone scatters, most of them die because literally the WHOLE MAP is filled with PAVN in amounts no one can beat without fortifications. Now again, Ammo cookoffs are quite realistic, but it's definetly an issue with how much everything explodes on Incursion maps.
Large cook offs are very preventable, not much I have to say I think they're fine, if annoying that they're >50% reason holds die.
- Enemy Deployment Ranges
A phenomenon very often seen on Khe Suong, you're set up around a bush as a natural barrier, firm wall of guns, then boom, PAVN keep dropping in on the SAME spot behind that bush you're next to, always out of firing line, they simply need to turn the corner to chuck nades and blow you up, how fun. But even worse: They drop directly into bases sometimes. And you better hope someone manages to kill all of them before even one of them can throw a grenade, but who am i kidding, they do that shit in one nanosecond anyways. I mean sure, they drop in from above because they paradrop, but normally you can shoot paratroopers in the sky, we can't. Least i'm pretty certain we can't...
I agree with the deployment it is ass, they deploy anywhere out of a player's line of sight and that is open to the sky, usually also nearest to players. Dean said something about an anti-air weapon preventing deployment but we will see.
As on how to fix those things? Honestly the main issue is volume of grenades, but enabling the GUNS we have to fire effectively at reasonable ranges would also just... be a good start. And difficulty isn't that hard to keep if their lackluster shooting were to be improved, or they received some AI Upgrades and new capabilities like building their own barricades, heck, they could already gain an advantage if their Sappers actually tried to circumvent defenses instead of being rebranded Soldiers with more boomy gadgets. Hell, giving some of them bulletproof shields that need bigger guns to penetrate would give them a different method to breach defenses without bordering on genuine bullshit, even a Tank unit would be better if we got AT4s or RPGs.
The sappers do try to circumvent defences to the point that island holds have become very popular and much better options than land holds, because in a land hold the enemy just blows a hole through a wall and flanks the base and instantly kills it. Do note that players have figured out that Hedgehogs aren't a valid sapper target and have been putting them in tunnels so they never breach tunnels.
My angle, personally, and the reason these complaints are issues for me, is because i enjoy good gameplay loops, and the feeling of becoming better at something, which Incursion hardly fosters well. Don't get me wrong, i like a good challenge, but i don't like bullshit. To me, the gameplay loop of Incursion just feels strained, and lackluster at the same time. You either sit behind an MG or next to the MG, you shoot Soldiers with underwhelming effective range while your screen CONSTANTLY SHAKES like it's trying to give me an Aneurysm or migraine, and every once in a while you get pelted with grenades and have to play ping-pong with the average Pro-CS player in terms of reaction time, only to have your backline fall, or a grenade blow up on you, sure, sometimes you win, sometimes you get out of the falling Hold, and most of the time you get gradually gunned down and pushed into a corner by Human Enemies with no self-preservation instincts. A conclusion that mostly leaves a sour taste, because losing on incursion comes down to little more than luck and chance, whether an enemy Banzai Charge has one or two too many for your line to handle, and how good you and your team are at clicking on a thing and throwing it back, which itself has a chance of being tossed right back anyways. It's frustrating, it's tiring, it heavily limits what strategies i can employ, and my godddd does it get picked way too much on the same map.
I agree with the screen shake and rounds going over your head, we're bullet proof (you cannot be hit in an upgraded trench while lying down) but still get affected by bullets?
 
The primary issue I have with Incursion right now is kinda just one issue that causes a few knock-on issues: that being AI reaction times

When a PAVN soldier gets into melee with you it will instantly pull out its knife (which is statistically identical to the player knife) and absolutely shred you harder than if they had actually used their gun, and that feels just broken. It's even more ridiculous because I've seen PAVN flamethrower units dual-wield their flamethrower and their combat knife, simultaneously lighting people on fire and stabbing them. It just feels very unfair with how quickly you are killed, there's not much you can do, I'm fairly certain xenomorphs do less DPS than these guys do and that just shouldn't be the case. I think they need either a worse knife so they shred players way less harshly, or a change to their AI so they pull it out much less quickly (maybe even with a progress bar to be quite honest) to show players to stay out of melee with them while they're doing a Banzai charge.

The second issue, and far more serious in my opinion, is AI behavior around throwing back grenades. They will do it virtually on the first frame the vast majority of the time, and even throw back grenades that you already threw back at them which just feels a little ridiculous and isn't fun to interact with at all, you essentially can't use hand grenades against PAVN at all because of this behavior because they are so good at throwing them back at you. You can't even turn their own grenades against them, you have to throw it to an unoccupied space because they will instantly throw it right back at you. There's just no way to really counter this, the intended behavior is people are able to throw the grenades to counter their aggressive rush but then they just... throw it back again with no delay. I don't even think the amount of grenades they throw is a problem, the amount of grenades thrown at fortified positions is what real-life soldiers would be doing, but I don't think anyone who has ever lived has the reaction times to play Tennis with your own hand grenades.
 
Back
Top